I think the Jimenez/Malloy trade made sense at the time. Jimenez finally had a good season at apthe age of 27. That was the time to flip him. Malloy’s defense simply hasn’t materialized at all.
I contend we don’t enough about what happened behind the scenes with the Rodriguez trade to know who botched it or how it was botched. He’d had the long term absence with little contact to the Tiger front office the season before. Then he nixes the trade because he doesn’t want to play out west. Then he signs with Arizona. Doesn’t sound like a, oh, how shall we say it, stable personality to engage with.