Considering the way that the defense can kick itself in the nuts, it might not matter if the Tigers have a pitching advantage. Its incredibly frustrating to watch poor defense, particularly on some of the more routine plays.
And its not just the plays that result in errors, its stupid plays like the lack of communication between CastroW and Reyes late in the game last night. The catch was made, but essentially it was good fortune that Reyes' mitt was higher than CastroW. Had the gloves been equal height, we're probably scribbling down a two base error rather than a 3rd out in our scorebooks.