I am cheerfully disagreeing! I want to be like the Braves, they roll out the same 8 guys, plus a catcher, every night and they don't give a crap about defensive versatility or L/R matchups. They accomplished this by finding good players, not chess pieces. What has changed, for us long time fans, is that the best athletes don't play baseball anymore. They play point guard, or read option quarterback. And that makes the Braves' accomplishment so much more impressive, and of course the best Caribbean or Venezuelan athletes don't play point guard or read option quarterback so maybe that's a clue.
That's what I'm hoping for, a drafting/developing regime that produces good every day players, like the Braves did, and a regime that doesn't behave as though platooning is an objective and not a compromise.