it speaks to my point that those teams were BUILT around hitting. they got fluke years from pitchers other than morris (who was steadily very good, but never great). they won when they got fluke good seasons from good pitchers but the core was always the hitters. dont confuse a fluke season from mcclain or willie hernandez as the "core" of the team.
im not saying youre doing that, but others are. those teams - and all the great tigers teams in old tiger stadium - were built on the foundations of great hitters.
cobb/heilman/crawford
gehringer/cochrane/greenberg
kaline/cash/horton/northrup
whitaker/trammell/gibson/parrish/evans/lemon
the tigers' problem has ALWAYS been pitching.