thibs is almost becoming underrated now. he's the "bendiest" of all the de's and the one that most profiles as a top top pass rusher.
he's got some flaws and because he's been the presumed #1 for so long people have had time to pick him over, but he's a better "pass rushing" prospect than hutchinson. hutch had a great year, but he's not "bendy", he's got great hands, is strong, and has a non stop motor, but he's not going to be able to go through nfl tackles the way he went through ohio state tackles.
hutch seems like a high floor high-ish ceiling guy, while thibs - with his injury history and perceived "character" issues - seems more of a lower floor but highest ceiling player. and i'm always wary of "character" and "motivation" concerns with prospects. i'd be fine if they took thibs.