I agree. He was one of those players that I liked from the beginning, but I found myself criticizing him a lot because he became so overrated.
Unforunately, my lasting image of him is his missed DP ball in extra innings in game 163. It wasn't an egregious error, but it was a play he makes 9 of 10 times. I was sure he was going to get the ball and my only question was whether he could turn two to win the game.