I didn't say they didn't know what they are doing. They know more than any of us. What I am saying is that if Keith is a capable defender at both positions, then he would have more value at second base. If he is deemed incapable of playing second base, that is disappointing, not because I think they are wrong but because I was hoping he would be a solid 2B. If he doesn't ever hit for the plus power that is generally expected of a first baseman, that would also be disappoining.