You are right. I don't pay much attention to manager awards, so I am not surprised I am wrong. Looking back at that season, I see that the Marlins were at around .500 in still in the Wildcard race well into September, so I can imagine writers mailing in their Girardi ballots early before the Marlins cooled at the end of the season. I don't think writers will view the Tigers season as extraordinary. Even as a Tigers fan, I don't view it as extraordinary. What I do see is an organization that appears to be catching up to the rest of the league in modern anaylsis and management. Hinch is part of that, but it's more of a positive new direction than one great season.