Tiger337

Seager has not been durable at all so far.

Correa is my choice, but the consolation prizes are good too.

Sure, but he'd still be better than Goodrum and the Castros.

People would complain if they got Honus Wagner. If Avila signs a bowlegged shortstop to a 10 year deal, I'm done with this team.

I just became a community regular!

Anyway, my feeling about Kreidler is: (1) I don't expect a lot from him. (2) He is worth keeping an eye on. (3) He shouldn't impact their winter shopping.

Every terrible player was too. 😀

I am expecting the Tigers to land one of the big five. It will be a bit disappointing if they don't. I am less confident they'll get Correa specifically, but I think they will make a legitimate offer.

I think it was supposed to be a joke in response to my sarcasm, but I'm not sure.

What about Kreidler?

Do we have any evidence that Baez hurt the clubhouse chemistry of other teams? Or is it just you not liking hotdogs?

The Clemens thing is fun to think about, but 17 other teams passed on him. It's like agonizing over not drafting Trout. There are so many players like that. The Tigers were really really cheap back in the 80s, so there is no way they were going to be the team to offer a big bonus to Clemens.

He has an unusual skill set. If he keeps doing what he's doing, he'd be a good addition. The problem is players who don't walk and who get a lot of their value from speed and defense tend to lose their value fast. I'd be particularly wary of a long term deal with him.

He is interesting although surprisingly he hasn't done better on the road than at home.

I don't know their budget. If there was a salary cap, I would worry about salaries. I doubt they will acquire Myers, but if they did I would assume they must have a very high budget. Either that or they are really stupid in which case, they aren't going to put together a good team anyway.

I never care how much money any player makes. Length of contract matters to me because it gets to be a problem when a washed up old player hangs around for three years at the end of his contract playing every day in the middle of the line-up.

That's a sad story. It sounds as Edmead was a budding star.

Right, it was not regarded as lopsided when it was made. Looking back though, I think May and Helms were overrated and would not be as highly regarded by today's metrics. And Morgan was a star in Houston by today's metrics although there was no way of knowing how great he would become in Cincinnati. I still say he was the most exciting player I have seen in his prime. He could do everything. He was Mike Trout with style.

I'd be fine with Story or Semien.

I think they will..just not the ones we want.

WAR last five years Story 22.5 Correa 22.3 Lindor 22.1 Semien 22.1 Turner 21.0 Baez 20.9 Bogaerts 19.9 Simmons 17.0 Seager 14.6 I am not really making a point here. They are all different ages playing under different conditions. I just think it's interesting how close the top guys are. This list includes players who played the majority of their games at shortstop. The Tigers have no such players. https://stathead.com/baseball/season_finder.cgi?request=1&match=career&order_by_asc=0&order_by=WAR_bat&qualifiers=nomin&minpasVal=3000&mingamesVal=1000&year_min=2017&year_max=2021&positions[]=6&exactness=anymarked&games_min_max=min&games_prop=50&type=b&age_min=0&age_max=99&season_start=1&season_end=-1&location=pob&locationMatch=is&isHOF=either

Correa will get more than 5 years for sure, but I think the contracts won't be as big as people think with high supply this year.

I still don't like the Dodgers.

November 29, 1971: Traded by the Houston Astros with Ed Armbrister, Jack Billingham, Cesar Geronimo and Denis Menke to the Cincinnati Reds for Tommy Helms, Lee May and Jimmy Stewart. So the Reds got the best player in baseball, a pretty good starter and a starting center fielder for May (2-3 win player) and Helms (1-2 win player).

That Joe Morgan trade was huge for the Reds!