Tiger337

tldr

Tigers with most WAR through age 24: Cobb 47 Kaline 34 Bush 19 Greenberg 16 Trammell 16 Fryman 16 Whitaker 14 Thompson 12 McCosky 11 Heilmann 11 Greene 11 Manush 11 Jackson 10 Freehan 10 sports-reference.com Player Batting Season & Career Stats Finder - Baseball | Stathead Find single seasons, combined seasons data for players with most home runs in single season, combined seasons, career and more. Get all of this data on Stathead and creat

They might need a bad boy on the team. They are one of the most vanilla teams I've ever seen. 😄

That's been the assumption with him, but the the Astros have performed well over the years with him on the team. So, I don't really have an opinion on whether he would be a good teammate. I know about the incident with the catcher last year, but it might be an isolated incident where he lost his temper or maybe others on the team hated the catcher too. Who knows? If the Tigers signed him, I would assume he was not a problem. I doubt we'll have to worry about that though.

If I remember correctly, the majority of people here liked that trade.

We all know.

What about Skubal?

Yes, I did say that you were acting sensitively. What you got wrong was why I was saying that. 😄

That's not what I said. I think that saying everyone wants wants Harris gone every time he gets questioned makes you appear sensitive.

He was right to make the deadline trades and lucky that things turned out different than planned. I think it's disingenuous to suggest that the way they made the playoffs that year was part of some grand scheme by Harris. That season was a lot of fun, but it was lucky and won't be repeated. It's interesting that the 2025 was pretty much the mirror image of 2024 which I think is more the ramdomness of baseball than anything they did wrong.

Even Chas thought that was a mistake.

I am very objective when it comes to player evaluatilon. Some posters here are very interested in the management side of the game and I like that about them. I am mostly interested in players though. I can't say what specific moves they should have made or should be making now. I just have an overall sense that Harris is very conservative and doesn't like to take risks compared to other GMs. I'd like to see him do more, but once the season starts, I pretty much accept what the roster is and enjoy the games.

Again, I think Harris is a good GM and I Iike his overall plan. I just think he is very rigid and I would prefer that he took more risks. I don't understand why people get so sensitive to any critique of Harris at all.

A top executive in a multi-billionaire dollar business fails to make one of the biggest deals of his tenure. I guess "there was nothing he could do about it" is a fair excuse.

He may have had input in their desperation run, but the fact is he traded key pieces at the trade deadline. You can maybe give him credit for giving Hinch the OK to execute pitching chaos, but he put the team in a position where it was almost impossible to win. I simply don't believe the plan was to trade two of their best pitchers at the deadline and then win with pitching chaos. That was an experiment to help them get through the season and a miracle happened. They kind of tried it again in the second half of 25 and it didn't work. 2024 was a lot of fun, but it was luck.

uh oh, you are going to be lectured!

You can say that about 25, but 24 was a fluke that will never be repeated again. Harris gave up on the season that year. Any credit for that season goes to Hinch and Fetter, but even that was largely luck.

Yeah, it probably would have gotten a "he won't sign here" from you.

I think most opinions here fall somewhere between "get him out of here" and being 100% satisfied with what he's doing. I may be closer to the latter than you think, but I still would like to see him do more.

Not worried, but missing the playoffs is a real possibility.

I think that too. It is not a terrible approach as pitchers are fragile, but I would still like to see them take chances once in a while. Imai wasn't really on my radar though.

I think they have a good chance of making it, so I'd like them to improve their chances while skubal is still here.

Yes

Imai signing with Astros for 3 years. Another east coast team...

I think they need a starter more than a bat. I have little faith that Olson will be healthy, Melton is a question mark and I am not excited about Drew Anderson. I'd like to see more offense too, but there is a better chance they get in-house help there than in the rotation.