Tiger337

Mize pitched like an allstar for a couple of months, but I wouldn't call him allstar caliber based on his whole body of work. If he pitches the same next year as last year, I'd say he is an average starter. I do think they could get Max Anderson for him, but that's pretty close to Chas's stated 10-20 range. He's right around 10 depending on the list. I wouldn't be OK with that, but they might get a little more. Still, I'd rather have Mize than anything they could get.

I don't trust Olson to stay healthy. I'm not even sure he's healthy now. Anderson is going to be 32 and has never done anything in the Majors, so I'm not expecting a lot from him despite his big season in Korea. Bassitt is old, but has consistently pitched 170+ solid innings per year. He's not exciting, but I like his chances this year better than Anderson.

I wonder how **** Allen would have reacted to arbitration?

Dombrowski did not like the process and wanted to avoid it every year.

I could imagine Eduardo Rodriguez going into a passive aggressive snit.

But if the Tigers had offered 25 million, the mid-point becomes 28.5. So, they would have better chance of winning. Offering 19 makes sense if you think that the arbitrator will arrive at a figure between 19 and 25.5. I am assuming that is what they think. Either that, or they underestimated the 32 million figure.

I turned 11 after the 1973 season, so I saw a 90 loss season at age 11 and 102 loss season at age 12. My Tigers glory years were from age 13 (Mark Fidrych in 1976) to age 23 (1987, the best Tigers pennant race ever).

Edman will probably learn that lesson in 20 years! Hopefully, he will see another Tigers championship by then. And hopefully, you and are still able to understand what's happening at that time.

Just like everything else in the world.

That too. I don't know why people get worked up about random power rankings based on opinions.

I see #1 in the AL Central. That's gets them into the playoffs. Once that happens, anything is possible.

The best part of this arbitration discussion is that it demonstrates that there are posters here that are even nerdier than me. 😉

I didn't think the thread was about arbitration.

No player has ever won an arbitation salary of more than 20 million. However, based on performance the 32 million dollar seems very reasonable to me. I know the arbitation scolds will scold me for that.

Three closers, but still no dominant reliever. That's OK, but I wouldn't say that their bullpen is a real strength. On the other hand, give Hinch some reliever depth and he can take it a long way.

Dombrowski would not have traded McGonigle for a 37 year-old closer. He would have traded Max Anderson for him. He would have traded McGonigle for a young star hitter close to free agency like he did for Cabrera. I don't want that kind of GM. I kind of want a GM with Harris's analytic and patient approach but with some of Dombrowski's boldness on occasion. Maybe, we'll see that eventually with Harris.

I think a lot of time when people mock minor league or waiver acquisitions, they are just being humorous and not being critical.

Complaining about stuff is good for the forum. I think once the season starts, it's best to accept the roster and enjoy the season. Then start complaining again at the deadline!

I don't remember Chas defending the acquistions of Paddack and Morton. He usually defends non-moves rather than moves.

I have one fantasy league that I've been in for about 20 years. Everybody puts in $200 at the beginning of the season. The money is divided among the top 3 in the league at the end of the season. It makes the season more fun, but that's the extent of my gambling activities. I agree it's good to stay out of professional gambling. It is designed to screw you and it feeds off addictions.

Hits like Hornsby. Hustles like Eckstein.

Here, it's mostly just ATF who wants that.

"pitching and three-run homers"

They aren't minimal. They are pervasive. It downgrades the viewing experience for me.

Short sighted maybe, but what part of that is that loony?