Leyland's best line in the speech:
"I asked my wife: did you ever think in your wildest dreams that I would make the Hall of Fame? She said: Jim You aren't in my wildest dreams"
Sparky was a character, but I agree he was probably not a great manager. Enough players have said good things about him for me to think he was a pretty good manager. However, I think he was better at managing veteran egos than developing young players. He had a lot of talent in place in both Cincinati and Detroit. It was hard to screw that up.
To follow up on this, these are the players I have identified as having 500 games and 2000 PA with three different franchises"
Rusty Staub - 4 franchises
Willie Keeler - had 10+ WAR with each
Doc Cramer
Johnny Damon - 10+ WAR with each
Darrell Evans - 10+ WAR with each
Curtis Granderson - - 10+ WAR with each
Steve Finley
Billy Buckner
Reggie Jackson
Omar Vizquel
If it was just left fielders, you could make a case for Greene because there is no clear cut chloice. Do they break it down by position or just take the top three outfielders? I see McKinstry is listed among utility players. With so many multi-position guys now, I'm not sure how they define that. I don't really care about Silver Sluggers anyway. It has an "everybody gets a trophy" vibe to it. Just pick the best hitter and leave it at that.
In 2024, the Tigers gave their team the message that they were giving up on the season and then they couldn't stop winning! So, maybe they needed that message! I don't think there is any way a fan can know the psychological impact any move will have on a team.
Even sim teams have long streaks or slumps for no reason at all. Last year, in a historical sim league, I got beaten by a team with an absolute **** roster. He had no idea what he was doing. I had the highest run differential in the entire league and didn't make playoffs. I lost so many one-run games. What a bunch lof chokers. 😃
If you go to newspapers.com, they've got a bunch of articles from that league. It looks like it was around for a long time - 60s through early 90s? If you want to go down memory lane, you could get a free trial. I had a subscrition for newspapers.com a few years ago when i was writing a little about Tigers history. It's a fun site.
December 10, 1996. The Houston Astros traded Doug Brocail, Brian Hunter, Todd Jones, Orlando Miller and cash to the Detroit Tigers for Brad Ausmus, José Lima, Trever Miller, C.J. Nitkowski and Daryle Ward.
I disliked the Fryman trade, but hearing that they traded him to clear money unecessarily makes it worse. I didn't know that at the time. Did Randy Smith make any good moves? Those 7-player trades with the Padres and Astros were fun but it was mostly just moving players around with no real impact.