Longgone

Scouting grades are not static. They depend on when you see the player. If you saw him struggling post recovery, sure he wouldn’t grade very well. He may, or may not, make it all or most of the way back.

If Keith’s defense ends up anywhere near average, leave him alone. If you can keep his kind of bat in the middle infield, that’s an advantage.

Campbell’s been a beast

You’re not fooling anyone with this crap. Does this amuse you? There are people out there with real mental health problems, and this vapid trolling just makes sport of their issues. Go find something constructive to do.

Reddick doesn’t fit any of the criteria. Can’t play de in detroit’s system, can’t cover from the sam, probably isn’t a culture fit

The first thing the Lions will be looking for is a de who can set the edge and maintain gap integrity as well as rush, and secondly, maybe someone who can rush from the Sam position, but he also needs to drop and cover. Reddick isn’t stout on the edge, and he’s not really a cover backer.

They need someone to replace Hutchinson or Davenport, that ain’t Reddick.

Develop both at catcher and hope one of them pans out.

What’s Vest? What’s Holton? Foley is certainly not perfect or the ideal, but he’s been solid and not deserving of all the angst.

This is being way overstated here. He k’s 7/9, not all that egregious, and opponents hit .228 off of him. He’s a solid option if he’s healthy.

I doubt they are coming to Detroit, but I doubt they’re staying put either. They will go to the highest bidder.

Those were the days, my friend.

Normally, I avoid the game threads because of all the whiny angst, but you guys have all made it so much fun the last month or so. Thank you so much!

Stop it

All of the above