IIRC, the evaluators knock on Paredes was that even if he hit, it was going to be empty BA because there there was no power projection. Since we have lost the board's history I can't look back to check that recollection.
But, if that was the case, they appear to have been wrong. Even in his slumping July Paredes has hit three more HRs.
But that would go more to why they never gave him the opportunity they gave others, and again, if that was the case, they were wrong.
Given that he had accomplished nothing at MLB and that Meadows' weird year was unforeseeable, the trade was fine. If the Tigers made a mistake with Paredes it was in their evaluations long before the trade.