the catch would have been hard because Austin didn't approach it optimally. A better OF gets to the wall, leaves himself a step so he can make the jump to adjust to the ball. Meadows certainly is capable of making that jump, he couldn't because he had already pinned himself against the wall. IOW, he was fielding the ball in a reactionary way instead of having been able to anticipate the play he should have made. And yes, that is exactly the difference between a plus OF and an average one.