Or do you let him start the inning but pull him before he pitches to India? That's one of the big shifts in the game brought about by the 3 hitter rule and more generally by the increased load on bullpens. Back in the day you'd have two relievers up and ready in the 6th, and in that scenario Jack isn't pitching to India after giving up the 1st hit of the inning. But Hinch doesn't have a RH reliever to burn on just India, Holton was prepping for Isbel, Hinch didn't want Holton against India. And in general everybody is more reluctant to burn up their relievers in the bullpen just being ready if you don't absolutely have to because you are most definitely not going to get a complete game the next day.