Jump to content

Edman85

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3,390

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    27

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Edman85

  1. Edman85
    Never repeated a level and the fifth season, when he would have been been slated for AA, was cancelled. It seems like the normal arc of a high school draftee. The above characterization is a bit off base.
  2. Edman85
    I would argue that finding talent is a glaring need, and just because two people have a similar resume, doesn't mean they have similar skills. It is clear as an executive, Al Avila was a failure, I'm not so sure we can definitively say that about Slater. Do you think Avila would have been able to work his way up the chain in St. Louis the past 15 years? We don't need somebody in the GM chair who knows Python, or can do a biomechanics assessment. We need somebody there who can effectively manage the people who can do those things, knows when they are succeeding, and get the different parts of the organization to work together effectively. I'm just not sure you are I is going to be able to assess these candidates without knowing them personally. And golly gee, as I check Linkedin, there's at least one poster here who does 🙂
  3. Edman85
    Henning had a name I hadn't seen, didn't uncover in my deep dive, but is followed by the entire Tigers beat on twitter. Cardinals Special Assistant to the GM: Matt Slater.
  4. Edman85
    The first Tigers teams I was old enough to follow had Tettleton, Phillips, Cuyler, Kreuter. I don't really have a way to fact check, but I know that era was switch hitter heavy.
  5. Edman85
    I tend to agree, in that a new GM and front office can come in and give these guys kind of a clean slate. I wanna add one thing to this calculus, though. It used to be arbitration contracts weren't guaranteed. You could give guys a tryout in March camp and cut them for severance pay. That's no longer the case as of the new CBA, and I could see more players getting non-tendered as a result.
  6. Edman85
    I'm not a big fan of the idea of Tork on the short side of a platoon.
  7. Edman85
    I did 😀
  8. Edman85
    Yeah, I addressed that in a later post when I reached out to somebody for a sanity check.
  9. Edman85
    Explaining the joke, not letting me edit:
  10. Edman85
    I would argue a lot of the highlight tweeting accounts are in the same bucket as Hasty/Emily. Take that tweet a couple weeks ago that showed a play Jung made that was really a very poor play at 2B, but they spun it as some great play. Tweeting highlights is obviously going to have some selection bias baked in unless you show their Javier Baez moments on sliders away.
  11. Edman85
    Is he funny or something?
  12. Edman85
    I have a really hard time being that dismissive of mental health stuff. It's going to take a lot more than "giving him a prozac..."
  13. Edman85
    I've done it. I had leave entitled, was unhealthily burned out in mid-December and abruptly used it. Wasn't fired, and now 8 or so years later currently near the top of the org chart. Read the book I linked. This is VERRRY common in baseball, particularly with guys fighting back from injury. It's tough and grueling.
  14. Edman85
    Somebody with some general knowledge of other painkiller situations suggested this likely is NOT that, simply because he is with the team and they would likely keep him away from others if that was the case. Carry on.
  15. Edman85
    Well, I know it's not just me who thinks this is a possibility.
  16. Edman85
    Even that might be a stretch outside of the Tigers Prospect Twitter Bubble. I'd need to see more to that argument than some proclamations.
  17. Edman85
    1. Health is part of development, but I'll put that aside since there is some luck and randomness there. 2. I just don't think this is borne out in the results relative to other teams. Yeah, the Tigers have done better developing pitchers than hitters, but still have had many flame out in recent years. Is Mize a development success when you take him 1-1? Is Manning a development success when he is taken 1-6 and takes six years to start to pitch well at the big league level? Are those guys development successes or tanking successes? Some other highish picks in recent years that flamed out: Adam Wolf, Hugh Smith, Gio Arriera, Beau Burrows. There has been a lot of stagnation on the international side: guys like Guzman and Montero to name a couple. The Tigers may be average/above averagish at best at developing pitchers, and certainly don't compare to (off the top of my head) the Guardians, Rays, Dodgers, Yankees, Brewers, Astros, Giants, etc. that just pump guys out and have numerous guys banging down the door ever year.
  18. Edman85
    I seem to have seen two things related to it and know it's a big problem in baseball. Put two and two together and suggested it might be four, and recommended a book that goes into the topic for further reading.
  19. Edman85
    I don't know, I said it smells like it. Struggling with rehab, mental illness. It's a big time underreported underside of baseball. It's my guess.
  20. Edman85
    Avila was the one who publicly floated the idea of voiding the contract, IIRC.
  21. Edman85
    Along those lines, some of this may be Avila dysfunction.
  22. Edman85
    How's the Tigers Season going, you may ask. It's going "Eddie is watching Big Ten Volleyball instead" well.
  23. Edman85
    I agree with this.
  24. Edman85
    Yeah, I wasn't really going at you. Just trying to stem the tide before people dump on him. https://www.amazon.com/Bigger-Than-Game-Restitching-League/dp/0806534877 Good book on this topic from somebody who lived it if anybody is interested.
  25. Edman85
    The Meadows thing reeks of painkiller addiction, which is a serious thing and doesn't deserve scorn.
×
×
  • Create New...